Girdling (Ringing) Experiment: Effects
Removing a ring of bark (including phloem, cortex, and cork) from a tree trunk while leaving the xylem intact demonstrates the unidirectional translocation of organic nutrients in phloem.
What Happens:
Immediate Effects (Hours to Days):
- Upward Water Transport Unaffected:
- Xylem remains intact
- Water and minerals continue moving upward from roots
- Leaves receive adequate water supply
- No wilting observed initially
- Downward Food Transport Blocked:
- Phloem removed in ringed area
- Sucrose and other organic solutes cannot move below the ring
- Upward translocation from roots (if any) also blocked
Short-Term Effects (Days to Weeks):
- Swelling Above the Ring:
- Sugars accumulate in phloem above the girdled area
- Osmotic pressure increases
- Bark swells and bulges
- Visible callus formation as plant attempts to reconnect
- Sugar Depletion Below Ring:
- Root system receives no photosynthates
- Stored starch reserves in roots depleted
- Root growth slows, then stops
Long-Term Effects (Weeks to Months):
- Root Starvation:
- Roots cannot perform cellular respiration (no glucose)
- Active transport of minerals stops (no ATP)
- Mineral/water absorption ceases
- Roots begin to die
- Shoot System Consequences:
- Although leaves still photosynthesize, water supply diminishes
- Leaves begin to wilt
- Photosynthesis declines
- Eventually, entire plant dies
Timeline:
- Herbaceous plants: Die within 2-4 weeks
- Woody plants: May survive several months using stored reserves
- Complete girdling: Fatal
- Partial girdling: Plant may recover if phloem reconnects
Why Does This Occur?
BEFORE GIRDLING:
↑ Water (Xylem)
Roots ⇄ Leaves
↓ Food (Phloem)
AFTER GIRDLING:
↑ Water (Xylem intact)
Roots ╳ Leaves
╳ Food (Phloem removed)
Diagram:
Bulge (sugar accumulation)
↓
┌────────────────┐
│ │
│ RING OF │ ← Bark, Phloem removed
│ BARK │
│ REMOVED │
│ │
└────────────────┘
↓
Growth below ring stops
Roots eventually starve
Biological Significance:
- Proves Phloem Function:
- Demonstrates phloem transports organic nutrients
- Shows downward translocation from source (leaves) to sink (roots)
- Agricultural Applications:
- Girdling: Used to increase fruit size (temporary sugar accumulation)
- Scoring: Partial girdling promotes flowering in some fruit trees
- Caution: Must be temporary or plant dies
- Ecological Impact:
- Animals (porcupines, deer) can accidentally girdle trees
- Disease/pests that damage bark can cause girdling effect
Recovery Possibility:
- If girdling is narrow (<1 cm) and treated quickly, phloem can reconnect
- Bridge grafting: Technique to bypass girdled area using scions
- Adventitious roots: May form above ring, creating independent root system
Historical Note: This experiment was famously conducted by Marcello Malpighi (1675), providing early evidence for phloem function.